SECORE – Coral reef restoration on Curaçao
– by Valérie Chamberland.
Valérie Chamberland is a PhD candidate at the Institute for Biodiversity and Ecosystem Dynamics (IBED) of the University of Amsterdam and works with CARMABI and SECORE on coral restoration on Curaçao.
In 2010, the SECORE Foundation, in close partnership with CARMABI and the Curaçao Sea-Aquarium, launched a restoration programme aimed at developing methods to assist in the recovery of the threatened and highly valued Acropora corals.
In contrast to more commonly used techniques which depend on the production of offspring by fragmentation of existing colonies, SECORE uses sexually produced offspring, which are reared under nursery conditions prior to reintroduction to the reef. Although corals are capable of reproducing clonally, sexually produced offspring are generated in far greater numbers and are genetically more diverse compared to asexually produced offspring. Preserving genetic diversity in remaining coral populations is crucial for their long-term survival because genetic variation increases the potential to adapt to environmental challenges, such as those faced by coral reefs.
SECORE’s research focuses on Elkhorn coral. To facilitate this species’ recovery, 370 Acropora juveniles were outplanted as primary polyps in 2012. Their survival rate after six months was 13%, which compares well to natural recruitment and survival rates that presently are approximately zero. Increasing the survival of outplanted corals would improve the effectiveness of existing restoration methodologies, but in order to do so, first the processes driving the survival and growth of newly settled corals needed to be explored.
Newly settled corals experience high mortality immediately after settlement as their small size makes them extremely vulnerable to (a)biotic disturbances. Coral recruits can die from multiple factors including competition, sedimentation, predation, diseases and bleaching. Processes occurring during early post-settlement life stages of corals strongly influence the local abundance of corals. Consequently, factors driving post-settlement mortality deserve special attention, as they strongly influence future populations. Improved knowledge of the ecological mechanisms which affect recruitment success of corals during their earliest post-settlement life stages holds great potential to improve the effectiveness of existing restoration strategies. Therefore, PhD candidate Valérie Chamberland (IBED, University of Amsterdam) started working with Dr. Mark Vermeij (Science Director, CARMABI) in May 2012 to study the ecological dynamics during the earliest life stages of corals to further increase the success of restoration efforts such as the SECORE programme. In the next three years, Chamberland hopes to be able to identify which factors have the most influence on corals during their early life stages.
At one specific day throughout the year, coral colonies synchronously release their gamete bundles that slowly float their way up to the surface, where they will break apart with the wave action. At the sea surface, floating eggs from a given parent will be fertilised by sperm from a second individual, sparking a complex sequence of development stages: embryogenesis.
The annual cycle of seawater temperature fluctuation dictates the month of gamete release while the day is set by the lunar cycle. Ultimately, the exact timing is narrowed down by the time after sunset and coral spawning will usually start a few hours after dusk. This is also when coral sperm and eggs are collected for restoration purposes. For well-studied species, the exact spawning timing can be predicted and on the expected evenings several colonies are monitored in the hope of collecting spawn from enough individual colonies to generate genetic variability.
After collection, all divers speed back to shore in a hurry to mix sperm and egg to allow fertilisation. After a few days, coral embryos develop into swimming planulae, which will eventually seek the bottom in search of a new home and settle to an artificial substrate within the SECORE land-based nursery at the Curaçao Sea-Aquarium.”
Coral restoration efforts on Bonaire – A joint nonprofit-private initiative
– by March Storm (Buddy Dive)
A meeting between Ken Nedimyer of the Coral Restoration Foundation in Florida and Augusto Montbrun, the manager of a commercial dive resort on Bonaire in 2009 resulted in an unusual partnership. The progress made by the Coral Restoration Foundation with coral restoration using farmed fragments of Acroporid corals in the Florida Keys fuelled Montbrun’s desire to bring this successful project to Bonaire.
After almost ten years of trial and error, the Coral Restoration Foundation developed a model called the “nursery tree”, reminiscent of an old-school TV antenna, from which small fragments of native Staghorn and Elkhorn coral colonies are suspended in the water column, making the whole system resemble an underwater Christmas tree. The coral fragments are harvested from remaining Acropora colonies in the waters around Bonaire. The “nursery tree” has a success rate of over 99% in the growing of healthy coral. This means that nearly all farmed coral fragments hanging in the nursery tree grow to be large enough to be planted out on the reef again.
In April 2012 the first coral nurseries were set up on Bonaire, with two ‘demonstration’ nurseries directly in front of the Buddy Dive resort and a more protected nursery off the coast of Klein Bonaire. The small pieces of coral colonies used are of varying DNA strains from different places around the island to ensure the preservation of diversity and boost spawning rates. The newly pruned coral fragments have seen an almost 100% survival rate and what started as pieces of coral just a few centimetres long, grew and branched out to almost three times their size in just nine months. The rate of growth on Bonaire is among the fastest the Foundation has seen in the world and they expect to see natural spawning within two years among the newly grown coral. Additionally, the remaining, healthy-looking colonies, which are believed to contain the most heat and disease resistant DNA strains are being identified and mixed with the apparently less resistant strains in order to preserve diversity on the island.
With the successful first year of the project completed, Buddy Dive along with the Coral Restoration Foundation and STINAPA Bonaire now plan to triple the size of the existing nurseries and begin the reintroduction process on shallow reefs along Bonaire’s coastline by planting out the farmed coral fragments back into the wild. These efforts lend a helping hand to the coral species that might otherwise be condemned to extinction and may provide the snorkelers and divers on Bonaire with an underwater experience that includes these beautiful branching corals teeming with juvenile fishes for generations to come.